Friday, August 22, 2025

Drowning in Silence

By Chae Santana

 -

She was different, the other kids often whispered about her, murmuring cruel things about her home life. They teased her for things beyond her control, I never joined in, but I admit I never spoke out either. I wish I had. But, I wanted to be liked. I wanted to belong, and on that day I wanted more than anything  to prove I wasn’t just a girl in floaties. 

That was why I climbed on the diving board that day. It wasn’t bravery that brought me up there but desperation. Desperation to be seen. To jump, and maybe, land among the kids who, for reasons I couldn’t explain, had a power over me. I wanted to show them that I could be like them. Like the girls who didn’t wear floaties, the girls who didn’t need them. I wanted to feel like I belonged. I wanted to be accepted. 

As I stood at the edge, knees bent, ready. I had no idea what was unfolding behind me. She was taking off her floaties, her lifeline. Without a word, without any warning. I hadn’t known it then, but she was making a choice I didn’t see coming. 

Then the screams erupted. 

I turned to see a limp body being dragged through the water. Then words broke through the panic “She tried to jump! She hit her head! I don’t know how long she’s been under!” 

The yelling hit me hard and echoed off of the pool’s wet tiles. It was hard to know what was happening at first, each of us clueless. The air was thick with the scent of chlorine , but beneath that was the unmistakable odor of fear. I watched as the lifeguards moved with a speed that felt unnatural, their voices quick, urgent, cutting through the tension like a blade. The water, which had just been playful, now felt like a hungry beast, something dark that could swallow us all.  

“She’s not breathing!” and within a few moments “No pulse.” 

I should have been horrified. I should have been terrified. I should have been devastated or sick with dread, but all I felt was relief. A deep, visceral relief that it wasn’t me. The selfish thought twisted through me faster than I could grasp it. It could have been me. It should have been me. 

I had been on the diving board only moments away from the same fate. I wanted to prove myself too. I took off my floaties to jump, to feel like I was worthy of their attention. If I had gone first, If I had acted just a moment sooner, It might have been my body lifeless, sinking in that same water.

The relief curdled, and something darker rose in its place. I felt as if my life was worth more than hers.

At that moment, I didn’t see the tragedy as her small body bobbed lifeless in the water. All I could think was that she had stolen my chance. She had taken the very thing I was so desperate for. Visibility. Her tragedy, her very life had become a roadblock between me and the validation I craved. 

Then came the guilt. It was cold and sharp, cutting through the darkness that had settled in my heart. How could I feel this way? How could I feel relieved? I was supposed to be the empathetic one. The girl who felt everything. The one who cried for fictional characters and dreamed for a world where no one ever suffered. And yet here I was, glad that it wasn’t me.

All of the sounds surrounding me blurred into a white noise, the crying students, the shouts for 911. I remember the young lifeguard, likely not much older than we were. His face pale and his hands trembling as he counted compressions. His chest heaved with broken sobs between each press, but his hands never stopped. The sickening rhythm of his desperation echoed throughout the room, the unforgettable sound mixing with the dreadful whispers of my peers. Combined, it had felt as if time itself had bent around that moment, stretching and pulling, the world was holding its breath.  

Someone, maybe a teacher or maybe just another student pulled me off of the diving board. I don’t remember who or how. All I remember is walking past her, past the frantic attempts to save her, past the cold body with foam seeping from its lips, and walking away.

The bus tumbled along, indifferent. I started out the window and imagined her still floating there, lost. The water wouldn’t let her go. I saw her blue lips, her arms limp like seaweed, her eyes glassed over.  To me she had never left the pool, instead her body stayed behind. She was sinking beneath the surface every time I blinked. 

I couldn’t bring myself to feel anything anymore. It was as if the whole world had fallen silent, and I was stuck in it.

When I got home, my mother and grandmother tried to talk to me. They wanted to understand what had happened, how I had felt. I couldn’t explain it, couldn’t find the words for a feeling I didn’t understand. I stared at the tv behind them, pretending to listen but really hearing nothing. I didn’t know how to process what had happened. All I could think was about how I felt nothing for her, how that absence of feeling seemed to confirm everything I had feared about myself.

In the days that followed rumors began swirling. Was she dead? Will there be a memorial? The silence around the situation only made it worse, amplifying the shame I had felt inside. How could they cry for her? These were the same kids who never spoke to her, who teased her when she wasn’t around. How was it that they could feel something I couldn’t?

Then, we learned the truth. She was alive. Stable. In the hospital. 

But still, I felt nothing. I was numb. I was empty.

She never came back to school. I never saw her again, never learned if she recovered. Her absence should have weighed on me, but it didn’t.

 It was as if she had never been there at all. 

 

About the Author


 

Chae Santana is in her first year at ICC. She likes to spend her free time reading, traveling, or watching true crime. She's majoring in sociology and likes to write as an outlet.

Featured Post

Table of Contents

Volume IV, Issue 2 August 2025 From the Editor Artwork Home Sweet Home by Timothy Angel The Wounded Man by William Douglas Pet...